Ireland Ambassador to Bulgaria Geoffrey Keating: EU Guarantees Were Crucial for Lisbon Treaty Ratification

Novinite Insider » INTERVIEW | Author: Ivan Dikov |October 3, 2009, Saturday // 18:57
Bulgaria: Ireland Ambassador to Bulgaria Geoffrey Keating: EU Guarantees Were Crucial for Lisbon Treaty Ratification Ireland's Ambassador to Bulgaria, Geoffrey Keating. Photo by BGNES

Exclusive Interview with Geoffrey Keating, Ireland's Ambassador to Bulgaria, on the Irish ratification of EU's Lisbon Treaty after a second referendum


Would you say the rather high percent of Irish voters supporting the Lisbon Treaty is a surprise? Had a “no” vote been equally likely until the last minute, or had the outcome been clear in the past few weeks?

In the run-up to the referendum, the polls suggested a swing in favour of the treaty although it was impossible to predict the size of the margin. It is now clear that there was a very substantial swing in favour of the treaty and we have a very definite result.

Six months ago you told that many people in Ireland “voted against the Treaty, or failed to vote, because they did not understand it.” Has the information campaign been better and more successful this time?

Without doubt, there was a very effective information campaign, involving not only the Government and the political parties but also a wide range of civil society representatives. This was reflected in the polls where there was a marked drop in the "don't know" category. There was also an intensive national debate about the treaty which helped to clarify the issues at stake.

What factors tipped the scales in favor of the Treaty: the information campaign; the legal guarantees by the European Council for “opt-outs” on abortion, taxation, and military neutrality; Ireland’s dependence on EU bailout aid because of the financial crisis; the sheer pressure by the rest of the EU; or something else? Which of those factors do you think was the most important for the “yes” vote?

There were a number of factors. First of all people were better informed about the treaty and its provisions. Secondly, the Government listened to people's concerns and addressed them by seeking guarantees on a number of issues from our European partners.

The main concern people had was the prospect of not being represented in the European Commission. I believe the decision to allow each Member State to continue to nominate a Commissioner is something that is of importance not only to Ireland but to all Member States, particularly the smaller ones.

There were also concerns about workers' rights and these were addressed in a solemn declaration agreed last June by the European Council.

You mention a number of other areas, such as taxation and neutrality. We were able to address these points by agreeing with our European partners a number of legally binding guarantees. It is a very good example of how the European Union works by listening to and accommodating the concerns of even the smallest Member States. This is what makes the European Union unique in world affairs and why I am glad to be part of it.

Would the Irish voters still be willing to back the Treaty if it had not been for the devastating effect of the economic crisis on the Irish economy, and the aid from the EU? Is it fair to say the Lisbon Treaty got ratified in Ireland thanks to the economic crisis?

I have no doubt that the crisis did influence people's decision. Over the past year, we have all been reminded that our prosperity and our economic security are closely bound up with our membership of the Union.

Did the Irish voters make a compromise with their position by reversing their own earlier vote, or is this a manifestation of the more acute realization that Ireland is much better off with the EU?

We have always been among the strongest supporters of the European Union and we still are. Our attachment to Europe has never been in question. The Irish people did have concerns about the Lisbon Treaty. These were addressed and the people have made a clear choice.

The Irish voters were bold enough to say “no” in 2008, and they have now passed the Lisbon Treaty only after securing opt-outs. What are the lessons from the whole Irish experience with the Lisbon Treaty ratification? For the small states in the EU such as Bulgaria? For the EU as a whole?

I don't like the word "opt-out". When it comes to Europe, Ireland opts in and not out. What we sought and secured from our partners were specific clarifications of the treaty and guarantees about its application.

There are lessons for all of us. The institutions of the European Union, whether it is the Council of Ministers, the Commission or the European Parliament, need to communicate and explain clearly what they are doing and why they are doing it. And the national authorities in each Member State need to engage more effectively with their people on European issues.

Overall, has Ireland met with much negativity within the EU after the “no” referendum in June 2008? Is the “yes” vote going to correct some negative effects that Ireland might have suffered as a result of the first referendum?

I did not have a great sense of negativity. Obviously, our partners were concerned by the delay in implementing important reforms that would help the European Union work better for its citizens. What really impressed me was the positive and sympathetic way in which our partners responded to Ireland's concerns.

What we all need to do now is to implement the provisions Lisbon Treaty and deal with the urgent challenges facing us, whether it is the economic crisis, climate change or energy security. Ireland is fully committed to working with our partners on the shared challenges ahead of us.

Do you think it is a fair approach on part of the EU to pressure for new referendums until the treaty is finally passed?

Let us be quite clear on this. After the outcome of the last referendum, the Irish Government analysed carefully the reasons why the people rejected the Treaty. They then moved to address those issues. Still convinced that the reforms contained in the Treaty were good for Europe and of benefit to the Irish people, the Government proposed holding a second referendum. In my view, the clear and decisive outcome of that referendum clearly justifies the approach that was taken by the Irish Government.

We need your support so can keep delivering news and information about Bulgaria! Thank you!

Interview » Be a reporter: Write and send your article
Tags: Geoffrey Keating, ireland, Ireland Ambassador, ambassador, Lisbon Treaty, Referendum, opt-out

Bulgaria news (Sofia News Agency - is unique with being a real time news provider in English that informs its readers about the latest Bulgarian news. The editorial staff also publishes a daily online newspaper "Sofia Morning News." (Sofia News Agency - and Sofia Morning News publish the latest economic, political and cultural news that take place in Bulgaria. Foreign media analysis on Bulgaria and World News in Brief are also part of the web site and the online newspaper. News Bulgaria