Bulgarian Deputy PM: EU Law Prevails in Land Moratorium
The Parliament's decision to extend the moratorium on the sale of land to foreigners is not consistent with the Constitution and the Treaty of Accession of Bulgaria to the European Union
This comment was made for the Bulgarian "24 Chassa (24 Hours) daily by Deputy Prime Minister and Justice Minister Zinaida Zlatanova.
She stresses it was 100% clear that where there is conflict between Bulgarian and European law, European law prevails and should be applied.
"We had a seven-year transitional period when we were not mandated to apply EU law on free movement of capital, and in particular - ownership of land. The moment this transitional period expired, we should automatically begin to apply the EU law. And it bans discrimination against foreigners regarding ownership of land," explained Zlatanova.
The Deputy Prime Minister added that so far no Member State of the EU has changed its accession contract.
Last Tuesday, Bulgaria's Parliament controversially decided to extend the ban on sale of agricultural land to foreigners until 2020.
The proposal for the extension was made by ultranationalist anti-EU party Ataka, a sort of kingmaker for the Socialist-led government. Surprisingly, it was backed by both the ruling Bulgarian Socialist Party and the opposition center-right Citizens for European Development of Bulgaria, GERB.
A total of 171 lawmakers voted in favor of extending the moratorium, while 38 were against and 12 abstained from voting. The biggest surprise were the Socialists, because all, except one, who took part in the debates, urged to reject Ataka's proposal, but at the end 59 of a total of 75 BSP MPs present voted in its favor.
The European Commission warned that this would breach Bulgaria's commitment to lift the moratorium, which expires at the end of 2013.
Chantal Hughes, spokeswoman for European Internal Markets Commissioner Michel Barnier said Bulgaria's accession treaty did not provide for any extension period on barring land sales and EC expected Bulgaria to open its market in compliance with its commitments.
If Bulgaria wants the moratorium to remain in force after the beginning of next year, then it will have to receive support from all the rest of the EU member states. This means a review of the pre-accession treaty as well as re-ratifying by all the 28 EU member states.
Any such review could result in Bulgaria being targeted by reciprocal action by member states, potentially extending labor market restrictions on Bulgarians by other EU countries, EurActiv said.
From January 1, 2014, Bulgarians will have full access to all EU countries' labor markets following the lifting of temporary restrictions put in place by several countries when Bulgaria joined the bloc in 2007.
The liberal, predominantly Ethnic Turkish party Movement for Rights and Freedoms (DPS) is preparing to refer the case to the Constitutional Court, which is expected to overturn the moratorium.
The moratorium has been blasted not only by DPS, but by all right-wing parties, which currently are not parliamentary represented, by the Speaker of the Parliament, Mihail Mikov, and other senior BSP functionaries, and by a number of legal experts.
Prime Minister Plamen Oresharski also opposes it, while GERB leader and former Prime Minister, Boyko Borisov, after a trip to the headquarters of the European People's Party, EPP, in Brussels, made an U-turn and stated his party fell prey to "collective insanity."
The ban actually extends only to EU citizens, who still can purchase land in Bulgaria by setting and registering a company for the fee of BGN 2.
- » EU’s 1st Ever Legal Instrument for Roma Inclusion Adopted
- » Domino’s Pizza CEO Defends Bulgarians against Immigration Hysteria
- » Bulgarians View EU Only as Donor, Says Foreign Minister
- » Bulgarians Protest Against Discrimination in UK
- » Bulgaria Receives Czech Humanitarian Aid
- » Bulgarian MEP Dubs Frontex 'Helpless Observer'
The moratorium is not worth the paper on which it is written. Neither does it prevent foreigners to buy land, nor will it ever be valid - or are the deputies that voted for it really so demented to believe that 28 EU member states will gladly agree and ratify a regulation that is clearly a breach of European (and therefore also Bulgarian) Law?
This is just the kind of action that shows how the populist parties in Bulgaria and the brain-dead Bolen-Siderov a**lickers from ATAKA view their electorate: as simple-minded, uneducated imbeciles that can be easily manipulated by such a nonsense - and which is supposed to distract the voters attention from the real problems in Bulgaria.