Bulgaria's PM is Out, but Austerity Remains. What's Next?
The economic ills that led to mass protests in Bulgaria earlier this week and led Prime Minister Boyko Borisov to quit aren't going to be easy to address.
By Tom A. Peter
The Christian Science Monitor
Bulgaria's national parliament accepted the resignation of Prime Minister Boyko Borisov yesterday, but the protests that drove him from office continue.
Today's peaceful demonstration, involving just a couple hundred protesters, is much smaller in scale than the earlier, violent protests that led to Mr. Borisov's removal. But the young activists say they are just now getting organized and plan to push for major social changes in the coming weeks to fight the corruption and financial woes that plague Bulgaria.
The last week of turmoil in the country – initially a response to high electricity bills and an overall declining standard of living, but quickly evolving into calls for an end to government corruption and major reforms – is in many ways reflective of a shift happening throughout Europe.
Across the continent, residents say austerity measures have cut too deep, and European society – particularly post-Communist nations in Eastern Europe like Bulgaria – is struggling to adjust to a new economic reality that can no longer support a wide array of state-sponsored social services. Now Bulgaria and many of its European counterparts must work to find a middle ground that supports economically sustainable social services, but the process will likely not be without its growing pains.
"There needs to be a balance, otherwise we will face a revolution. But in terms of social policy, this balance will never get back to what it used to be twenty years ago. From now on, and I tell this to my students, they can't expect to have the same provisions as their parents," says Emilia Zankina, an assistant professor in political science at the American University in Bulgaria. "There will be a readjustment of expectations, but also a redefinition of the government role."
Among those who've taken to the streets in protest, one of the central frustrations is that many of the same figures have occupied their government for nearly two decades now. Activists blame an immobile old guard, rooted in the past and short on new ideas, for many of the nation's ills.
"We didn't complete our transition to a democratic country with an open market. The transition failed in this country," says Panayot Nikolov, an unpaid consulting intern and recent graduate who was among the protesters. "I am part of a new generation and we are waking up."
Bulgaria is the poorest country in the European Union. The average resident's monthly salary is less than 0 per month and has not increased for years. The nation was hit particularly hard by the global recession in 2008, which led to a tenfold reduction in foreign investment.
Like many of its neighbors, Bulgaria has sought to shore up its economy through a number of austerity measures, including freezing government salaries and delaying payments to the private sector.
"Bulgaria is one of the examples that you cannot revitalize the economy with austerity," says Rumen Gechev, director of the Center on Sustainable Development at the University of National and World Economy in Sofia. "In order to restore economic growth, you have to stimulate investments. There is no other way. How will you stimulate investments with austerity? Decreasing the purchasing power of households, not paying the private companies?"
Mr. Gechev adds that there is unlikely to be any serious improvement in the Bulgarian economy without first finding a way to improve citizens' average income. Low wages are what makes a problem such as soaring electric bills crippling for many Bulgarians.
Jivko Hristov, who spontaneously joined in Friday's protest, says that his grandmother's monthly electric bill now exceeds what she receives from her pension. Mr. Hristov, an unemployed plumber, says that even when he had work, many of his clients did not pay him at the end of a job because they simply did not have the funds.
"The Bulgarian people are poor and we cannot pay our bills," he says. "The problem is that we cannot live like this anymore."
- » EUObserver: Bulgaria Eyes Greek Crisis Warily
- » World Bank: Bulgaria Needs to Increase Productivity to Battle Demographic Crisis
- » Bloomberg: Grexit Threatens Bulgarian, Romanian Banking Industries
- » WSJ: Pro-Western Bulgaria Is One of Putin's Targets
- » NY Times: Bulgaria Fears Spillover of Greece Baking Trouble
- » The Guardian: Sofia Is 'Social Behind a Socialist Facade'
unfortunately, having been raped by the top dogs, the secret police and various other commie stooges in the years following the fall of communism, there's absolutely nothing of any value left in the government and public hands on which to base any kind of return to those values. the only way for Bulgaria to become a decent place for average citizens again is to attract foreign investment by reducing corruption, bureaucracy and barriers to investment. sadly as soon as any foreign firm look like making a small profit, they are branded "filthy foreign parasites", whilst the real parasites who, for example, make 1 million leva from using their psychology degree to "consult" on a hydroelectric engineering project, are seen as heros to millions.
It seems to me that if, as Mr. Peters suggests, the people of Bulgaria are "struggling to adjust to a new economic reality that can no longer support a wide array of state-sponsored social services ", then it seems to me that what they ought to do is destroy the "new economic reality", so that they can obtain the state-sponsored social services that they desire. Economic realities are made by the people. The country and nation of Bulgaria, and its institutions, belongs to the people who inhabit it. If ever they should grow weary of the existing government, they can exercise their constitutional right of amending it, or their revolutionary right to dismember and overthrow it. All power to the people. Destroy the "new economic reality".