Steve Hanke: Fiscal Discipline Prize Should Go to Bulgaria
Johns Hopkins economist Steve Hanke, who designed the currency board in Bulgaria in the 1990s, has praised the country as a star pupil in terms of fiscal discipline.
"The prize should go to Bulgaria," Hanke said, speaking for the BBC program "In the Balance", which stared last week into the banking black hole of debt.
The program discussed how best to navigate away from the huge debts faced by many European banks and how to deal with banks that have broken the law.
"Bulgaria was completely bankrupt by the end of 1996 and had hyper-inflation that peaked with a monthly inflation rate of 242%, in February 1997, wiping out the banks and the country."
"I was President Stoyanov's adviser at the time and we installed the so called Currency Board, absolutely rigid and solid banking regulations, which are counter-cyclical and mean that in the good times you are putting a lot aside."
He pointed out that Bulgarian banks' marginal reserve requirement went up to 12% in the last boom and now it has already been lower than 7%.
"Right now Bulgarian banks capital adequacy is running at 16.7, which is way above normal levels. They provision for non-performing loans in a rigorous way and require that the provisioning occur almost automatically. But the banks have a lot of capital and they can provision. The thing is solid as a rock."
Hanke has recommended for months that Sofia stay out of the euro and has recently took a firmer than ever stance.
"It would be a complete disaster if you did not have the currency board, " Hanke said in an interview for bTV private channel during his visit to Sofia last month.
"Bulgaria has a system, which is working perfectly right now. Why do you want to fix something that's not broken? I don't think you should be in the euro zone, period," the Johns Hopkins economist, who designed the currency board in Bulgaria and in several other east European countries in the 1990s, said.
"Bulgaria's monetary arrangement is much better than Europe's monetary arrangement. You have monetary sovereignty; you have control over your money. What if the euro blows off? Bulgaria can just switch to the US dollar!"
Bulgaria's currency board has forced its government to control spending, as the central bank is not free to print money to support government borrowing.
Every lev in circulation has since been backed 100% by foreign exchange reserves at the national bank—first the mark, and since 1999 the euro. This arrangement is known as a currency board and is much stronger than a mere currency peg. That's because in principle under a currency board the central bank could meet any speculative attack on the lev by accepting levs in exchange for the euros the bank holds in reserve.
According to Hanke adoption of the euro would trigger "a real mess" in Bulgaria.
He firmly denied allegations that the rigidity of the currency board system prevents economic development and ruled out the need for Bulgaria to phase out its currency board
Bulgaria today would not only meet the Maastricht Treaty's criteria for joining the euro zone - it would be one of its star members, a point that Hanke stressed upon.
Hanke, who served as an adviser to President Petar Stoyanov from 1997-2001, recommended shrinking further the state, saying this is the only way to fight corruption.
Public support for Bulgaria's eurozone membership has been seriously dented over the last year and a half following the troubling developments in the monetary union.
While at the end of 2010 the Bulgarian society was cut in two over calls for immediate introduction of the European single currency, recent surveys have found out that those who oppose euro adoption now are a huge majority.
A survey by bTV private television shows that a total of 77% of the respondents want the country to continue operating in the Currency Board regime.
According to analysts the Currency Board regime enjoys great public support in Bulgaria and is one of the few and most trusted institutions.
- » Bulgarian Finance Minister Meets IMF Representatives in Washington
- » Bulgaria's Municipalities to Get EUR 630 M Under EU Program
- » Greece Launches EUR 3 B Bond Emission on Markets
- » Romanian Senate Agrees on EUR 100 M Aid to Moldova
- » Bulgaria's Lawmakers Adopt Consumer Credit Act Amendments
- » The End of Windows XP Support Could Hurt ATM's