Bulgaria PM Boyko Borisov attempted Tuesday to calm down the environmentalist lobby, after the recent protests against the new GMO Act, by stating "I guarantee that we won't have GMOs".
The Bulgarian Environment and Water Ministry soon, of course, followed their leader by confirming that the new changes in the Law on Genetically Modified Organisms will not apply to food and animal feed. They added that the scope of the new law includes only laboratory research and release of GMOs into the environment including field trials.
Even with this apparent clearing up of the problem, I wonder if the Environment Ministry really knows how important the last point in their press release was - as it could lead to the end of mankind! Now before you give up reading, after deciding that yours truly has gone completely mad, here is a quote from Albert Einstein: "If the bee disappeared off the surface of the globe then man would only have four years of life left. No more bees, no more pollination, no more plants, no more animals, no more man."
Yes the little bee has a very important role in the battle against GM Crops. Bees are 100% needed for the pollination of Bulgaria’s crops, particularly oilseed rape, sunflowers and beans and are therefore absolutely vital for the rural population of the country. In fact the value of honey bees' services as pollinators in the European Union has been estimated at over EUR 3 B per year.
The changes to the GMO Act would allow for field trials of MON 810 maize (produced by biotech giant Monsanto) as well as other GM crops to take place in Bulgaria. MON810 is the only GM crop grown commercially on a large scale in Europe, and has so far been banned in 7 European countries, including Greece and Germany but not Bulgaria.
What is the link between bees and the GM Maize that could be grown in Bulgaria?
Well, bees collect pollen for food and in the US it has been found that pollen from maize fields can make up to 20% of the total collected by bees from nearby hives. It was recently made clear by many environmental organizations that domestic bee populations are in steep decline in areas where GM maize is grown. Wild bees, which are also vital for the survival of many of our wild plants, as well as being important for crops, have also started to disappear in these areas.
The theory goes that the genetic modification of the plant leads to the concurrent genetic modification of the flower pollen. When the flower pollen becomes genetically modified or sterile, the bees will potentially become malnourished and die of illness due to the lack of nutrients and the interruption of the digestive capacity of what they feed on through the summer and over the winter hibernation process.
Recently Walter Haefeker, a director of the German Beekeepers Association (DBIB) and vice president of the European Professional Beekeepers Association, warned that "the very existence of beekeeping is at stake," over this threat.
In addition, research has also found that bees can pass proteins from nectar unchanged into honey. If GM crops produce novel proteins or toxins in the nectar as well, this may further threaten the safety of the honey produced from areas where GM crops are grown.
GM plants may also contain genes which provide resistance to commonly used antibiotics such as ampicillin. There is concern that these could be passed on to the bacteria that live in humans and animals. DNA from pollen has been found to be able to survive in honey for seven weeks.
In spite of the risks, there has been almost no safety testing of GM pollen, either for humans or for bees!
In the specific case of Bulgaria, the government and PM Boyko Borisov have not yet shown that they are against GMOs, despite the soundbites. Sadly if they don't take swift action by banning MON810 they will not be able to stop the eventual destruction of the Bulgarian environment. Please Boyko save the bees before its too late!
Author: FIGMENT, 2 Feb 2010 16:50:30
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
Gee, it sounds like it is high time to come up with some genetically modified bees!
Seriously, this is scare mongering of the most disgusting kind. When in doubt, make up scary stories that have no basis in reality.
Author: ednpaz, 2 Feb 2010 21:43:43
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
Why do you assume he's making this all up? Do you think all these people, particularly professionals in the field (and Einstein) don't know what they are talking about?
It is clear that we are slowly but surely destoying our earth particularly in ways we are not even aware of. Most of this destruction comes from interest groups wanting to make more money and in an easier way. I really hope that Bulgaria one of the most beautiful counties in the world will stand strong and resist the economic temptation of Monsanto and say no to this potential danger. At least they should study the potential danger before continuing any further.
Author: Bill, 2 Feb 2010 22:19:23
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
ednpaz:
"resist the economic temptation of Monsanto and say no to this potential danger"
That's exactly the point in dispute. Nearly everything in life is a POTENTIAL danger, especially something normal misused, like the kitchen knife. Until there's credible proof that a danger DOES IN FACT EXIST, there's no reason for all this protestation.
If we avoided every POTENTIAL danger, we might as well stay in bed and starve.
Author: DrFaust, 3 Feb 2010 09:38:39
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
Bill,
"If we avoided every POTENTIAL danger, we might as well stay in bed and starve."
I get your point, but it is not about avoiding every potential risk, it is about how to assess the practical risk of genetically-engineered or manipulated seeds. And here, the danger seems to be really much higher as you seem to realize. Most medicaments will be useless after a few years, especially antibiotics. I don't see anyone denying this fact, even Monsanto experts agree about that in principle. And this is only one of the very concrete consequences.
One more thing: the use of Monsanto seeds makes these countries 100% dependent on the future supply of these seeds by Monsanto, since the crops from these seeds don't produce fertile seeds, so for the next harvest you have to buy again at Monsanto or you will starve. I don't consider any such dependence a good policy.
Author: Bill, 3 Feb 2010 10:37:46
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
DrFaust:
I can see your economic point very well. What I disagree with is the panic before the storm program.
Much as I disagree with Nellie, I think she's right on this one. People have been eating genetically modified food for the last several years, and to date no harmful effects have been claimed.
Just like--at least in the US--people have been eating ham and eggs, bacon and eggs, and steak and eggs for breakfast for generations, all before anyone had ever heard of cholesterol, and they all survived.
What I object to is the use of "may" or "might" in these studies about what causes what malady. OK, they "might", but do they? A certain amount of preventive medicine is always called for, but only for known reasons.
One of my barracks roommates in Naples was a Hospital Corpsman from the Preventive medicine unit. One of the bigproblems with the personnel of all of the services stationed there was the recurrence of venereal disease.
He said, "They come in tell me, 'hey, Doc, she was clean. She had a certificate'. those certificates aren't good for more than half an hour after the inspection".
The way he put it was, "Anyone who goes with these girls is welcome to EVERYTHING they get".
Author: FIGMENT, 3 Feb 2010 14:32:38
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
Bill
" One of my barracks roommates in Naples was a Hospital Corpsman from the Preventive medicine unit. One of the bigproblems with the personnel of all of the services stationed there was the recurrence of venereal disease."
Is that why you never slept with any women, only with your roommates? lol
Author: FIGMENT, 3 Feb 2010 14:41:42
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
Hey, it's a free world. No one has to buy sterile seeds from Monsanto if they don't want to. Monsanto is just another seller of seeds. If you don't like them, don't buy from them. I don't understand what the fuss is about. The liberal wingnuts want to make Monsanto seeds illegal? What idiots! I hate liberal Eurotrash!
Personally, I wouldn't buy any grapes that have seeds or any watermelons that have seeds. I don't give a damn if the corn in my breakfast cereal is genetically modified or not. And I know the Haitians waiting for us to feed them don't give a damn one way or another. So, piss off with that nonsense.
Author: Bill, 3 Feb 2010 15:19:48
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
Nellie:
"Is that why you never slept with any women, only with your roommates? lol"
You have a VERY dirty mind!
Author: viking, 3 Feb 2010 17:23:34
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
Bill,
Your statement " in the US--people have been eating ham and eggs, bacon and eggs, and steak and eggs for breakfast for generations, all before anyone had ever heard of cholesterol, and they all survived."
Two things:
Every health care professional in the world disagrees with you on the cholesterol and more important;
No one "survives" this veil of tears. Not even you, Bill.
Author: JKS, 3 Feb 2010 18:07:00
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
" in the US--people have been eating ham and eggs, bacon and eggs, and steak and eggs for breakfast for generations, all before anyone had ever heard of cholesterol, and they all survived."
http://www.data360.org/dsg.aspx?Data_Set_Group_Id=195
"food" for thought.
Not that anyone would want to live past 65 anyways :)
Author: WickedWitch, 3 Feb 2010 18:29:16
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
Holy crap, Bill will use even the most tenuous link as an excuse to tell his misogynist anecdata. Hateful, sad little man.
Author: FIGMENT, 3 Feb 2010 18:30:03
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
JKS
What is your point? We are eating all kinds of crap in the US and our life expectancy is still going up? I think it is genetic more than anything else. If you have good genes, you can eat, drink, smoke, do whatever you want, and you will still live to be 100. If you have cancer, high blood pressure, diabetes, or heart problems in your genes, you are fcuked, no matter what you eat or don't eat. The latest scientific findings show that the fewer calories you intake, the longer you will live.
Author: Bill, 3 Feb 2010 18:34:33
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
Viking:
My sister has a theory, and I suspect she's right. She says the "old folks" could get away with a cholesterol-loaded breakfast because they were involved in harder manual labor than we are today.
There are a number of specialists I don't agree with, so that doesn't bother me much. (Dr. Spock's ideas on child raising come to mind.) I just would like to be able to eat as much at one time as I could then. For the most part, restaurant portions are now too big.
But that's more or less irrelevant to the subject under discussion, namely panicking before the danger's known. My point was that people were living long lives without heart trouble or vein clogging long before cholestorol was discovered.
Author: FIGMENT, 3 Feb 2010 18:35:41
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
Bill
Thank you.
Now say something stupid so I can debate you and kick your arse.
Author: Bill, 3 Feb 2010 18:40:54
Boyko's Bees: Bulgaria GMO Act Puts Mankind at Risk
WW:
Swooping in with character assassination again! What does misogyny have to do with frequent cases of veneral disease because of having sex with women who weren't as clean as they claimed to be? It was a MEDICAL statement, not either sexist or dripping with misogyny.
You're just too damned sensitive with your virulent feminism, and you take every unfavorable comment about women as a personal slam. It may come as a shock to you, but women are no more perfect than men. You're more imperfect than most of the women I know.
But the fact remains that you still can't post without trying to degrade someone, and you'll keep quiet for days, waiting for the opportunity,
And you have the gall to call me small and vile? I'm pristine compared with you.